Closing rule: options for RedBird
Nov 19, 2026
We recommend choosing the closing rule per sale, from two presets, set before the sale is public and shown on every lot page and on the bid button. By default, Tier 1 timed closes let only earlier bidders continue, and everyday timed sales use an open extension of 3 to 5 minutes with a cap you set.
The decision
When a bid comes in close to a lot's scheduled close, what happens to the close, and who can keep bidding? This applies to timed closes; a live close run by an auctioneer needs no clock rule.
A · Earlier bidders only. After the scheduled close, only people who already bid on the lot can continue. Each rival bid resets a 5-minute window. No cap.
B · Open extension. Anyone can bid. A late bid adds a few minutes, up to a cap you set.
C · Per sale. You pick A or B for each sale, and the rule is shown on every lot page.
What you told us
On 18 Nov your auction side's view was relayed on the call, described for a live auction in the room, and your team raised the other side of it.
Your auction side: a late bid extends the lot "by another five minutes, meaning the auction could stagger out several hours after the proposed end time"; "plus five minutes with no cap"; and the bidder "has to place a bid before the scheduled auction time".
Rules per item: "maybe ... we can have individual rules."
The other side: "I understand how that's technically fair, but why bar new bidders from coming in if the clock's still running?"
How others do it
Houses fall into two camps. Heritage, RR Auction and The Realest let only earlier bidders continue; fine-art houses and most platforms let anyone bid and add a few minutes. Houses that vary the rule do it by sale type or category. We found none that varies it lot by lot inside one sale.
| House | Who can bid after the scheduled close | What a late bid does | Cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heritage | Only people who already bid on that lot | A window of 5 to 30 minutes, set by category (Signature Sports 30, Signature Movie Posters 10, Sunday Internet Movie Posters 5). "Only a bid from another bidder will extend bidding" | None stated |
| RR Auction | After 6 pm ET, only those who bid on the lot before 6 pm. A lone bidder at 6 pm wins. Lots with no bid stay open to all until their first bid or 7 pm | After 7 pm a lot closes after 30 minutes without a bid; raising your own maximum does not reset it | The house may close at its discretion |
| The Realest | Extended bidding "limited to those original bidders", only if two or more bid | Each bid resets a 15-minute timer | None stated |
| Sotheby's (online) | Anyone | A bid in the final minute adds 2 minutes | Up to 2 hours |
| Christie's (online FAQ) | Anyone | A bid within 3 minutes of the close adds 3 minutes | Not stated in the FAQ |
| Phillips (online) | Anyone | A bid in the final 3 minutes adds 3 minutes, to that lot only | None stated |
| Bonhams (online) | Anyone | A bid in the last 5 minutes adds 5 minutes, until bidding stops | None stated |
| Propstore (timed online) | Anyone | A bid in the last minute adds 5 minutes; lots close one by one | None stated |
| Julien's (online) | Anyone | A bid in the last minute resets the timer to 2 minutes "until competition stops" | None stated |
| Invaluable (timed) | Anyone | A bid in the last 5 minutes extends 5 minutes from that bid | Until 2 hours after the last lot's scheduled end |
| LiveAuctioneers (timed) | Anyone | "The auction house sets the extension period for its own auctions" | Set by the house |
| Goldin | Not stated | 15-minute extended bidding for Weekly sales, 30 minutes for Elite | Not stated |
| eBay | Anyone | Long a hard close. Now "testing extended bidding on auction listings in some categories": a bid in the final 60 seconds resets the clock to 60 seconds | Not stated |
What the research says on price. A peer-reviewed study of eBay (hard close) and Amazon (automatic extension) found late bidding far more common under a hard close: 40% of last bids in Computers and 59% in Antiques came in the last five minutes on eBay, against about 3% on Amazon (Roth and Ockenfels, 2002). Its revenue point is theory, not data. No one has published price data comparing "earlier bidders only" with an open extension, so the choice is judgement plus a test, as set out below.
What the rules say
We found no US rule on how a timed close must work. What matters is that the rule is written into your conditions of sale before bidding opens and shown to bidders. Your legal team confirms the wording.
Options compared
A protects bidders who committed early; B lets anyone join while the clock runs; C uses each where it fits.
| A · Earlier bidders only | B · Open extension | C · Per sale (recommended) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collectors | Fair to those who bid before the close; a late arrival is shut out after it | Anyone can join while the clock runs | Tier 1 bidders get A, everyday buyers get B |
| Consignors and studios | Competition among committed bidders, no sniping | Late arrivals can still add bids | Each sale gets the rule that suits its lots |
| Length of the close | Ends itself: with no cap, the pool of bidders can only shrink | Can run for hours without a cap; a cap you set stops it | Bounded either way |
| Risk | A late, high-value buyer may be lost | Snipers wait for the clock | Two rules can confuse, unless named the same everywhere and shown on every lot |
| Operations | One rule to explain | One rule to explain; staff on duty for long closes | One setting per sale, fixed before the sale is public |
| Fits what you told us | Your auction side's "plus five minutes with no cap" | "Why bar new bidders" | Both, and "individual rules" set per sale |
Our recommendation and why
We recommend C: you choose one of two presets when you set up each sale. The rule is fixed before the sale is public, never set per lot and never changed mid-sale. It shows on every lot page, on the bid button and in the bid confirmation email.
A · Earlier bidders only. Default for Tier 1 timed closes.
After a lot's scheduled close, only people who bid on it before then, including with a maximum bid, can continue.
Only a rival's bid resets the 5-minute window; raising your own maximum does not.
No cap. If only one earlier bidder is left at the scheduled close, they win then.
A lot with no bids at its scheduled close stays open to everyone until its first bid.
B · Open extension. Default for everyday timed sales.
Anyone can bid. A bid in the last 3 to 5 minutes adds the same 3 to 5 minutes, set per sale.
A cap you set. Sotheby's and Invaluable use 2 hours.
Why:
Per sale is how houses vary it. Heritage sets the window by category, Goldin by sale type, and LiveAuctioneers leaves it to each house per auction. None varies the rule lot by lot inside a sale. Your franchise sales and tiers already group lots, so "individual rules" per sale meets the need.
A is well tested in collectibles. Heritage, RR Auction and The Realest use it, and it matches the rule your auction side described for a live room auction; we apply it to Tier 1 timed closes. The details above copy how Heritage and RR make it work.
B answers "why bar new bidders". It is the norm at Propstore, Julien's, Bonhams and Invaluable, and suits everyday sales where we want newcomers to be able to join late.
A is fair to late arrivals too. Anyone can bid at any time before the scheduled close, and Tier 1 sales are public for weeks (see How long a sale is open). Reminders 24 hours and 1 hour before the close prompt watchers to place a first bid.
Showing the rule on every lot goes further than Heritage. The Game of Thrones lot page we opened carries no closing-rule text, only a link to the terms.
What we take on and what we need from you
Povio takes on:
Both presets in the bidding flow, chosen per sale at set-up.
The rule in plain words on every lot page, on the bid button and in the bid confirmation email.
Close reminders to watchers, 24 hours and 1 hour before the scheduled close.
A close report after every sale (see How we'll measure it).
We need from you:
The preset for each sale.
Confirm the 5-minute window for A, and the extension and cap for B.
Your legal team confirms the conditions-of-sale wording.
How we'll measure it
We report these after every sale, split by preset, so A and B can be compared on real results:
Share of lots that go into extension, and minutes past the scheduled close.
Bids per lot during the extension.
Under B: share of winning bids from people who first bid in the last hour.
Under A: bids refused after the close from people who had not bid before.
Prices against estimate.
Sources
Heritage, Auction types, read 19 Nov 2026
RR Auction, Terms and Conditions, section 11.11, read 19 Nov 2026
The Realest, How does the bidding process work, read 19 Nov 2026
Sotheby's, Buy and sell, read 19 Nov 2026
Christie's, Frequently asked questions, read 17 Nov 2026
Phillips, Online-only FAQ, read 19 Nov 2026
Bonhams, How to bid online, read 19 Nov 2026
Propstore, Auction FAQ, read 19 Nov 2026
Julien's, How to bid, read 19 Nov 2026
Invaluable, Bidding FAQ, read 19 Nov 2026
LiveAuctioneers, How do timed auctions work, read 19 Nov 2026
Goldin, About, read 19 Nov 2026
eBay, Bidding help, read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Game of Thrones lot 7366-89729, read 19 Nov 2026
Roth and Ockenfels, "Last-Minute Bidding and the Rules for Ending Second-Price Auctions", American Economic Review 92(4), 2002, read 19 Nov 2026